A MOTION to be debated at Cornwall Council next week asks that local housing need should be prioritised and the council should withdraw from discretionary resettlement schemes which provide homes for refugees and asylum seekers in the Duchy.

The motion has been proposed and seconded by Cornwall Council’s two Restore Britain councillors, Roger Tarrant and Bruce Craze, who both defected from Reform UK. It has been supported by two Reform councillors, Cliff Crawford and Ian Wilson, and Susanne Desmonde, an Independent Non-Aligned councillor who is also a former Reform UK member.

The motion calls on the Liberal Democrat / Independent coalition Cabinet to “withdraw, so far as legally and contractually permissible, from participation in any discretionary refugee resettlement scheme that places additional pressure on Cornwall’s social housing, emergency accommodation, temporary accommodation or essential public services”.

A discretionary resettlement scheme is a government-led or humanitarian programme that relocates displaced people, refugees or asylum seekers to a new location based on case-by-case judgement, policy choice or special vulnerability rather than a strict, automatic legal entitlement.

Cornwall Council supports three migration and resettlement-related schemes of which only one is discretionary – the Afghan Resettlement Scheme. Afghan resettlement programmes have been running in Cornwall since December 2023 with a total of 30 families living across Cornwall.

The UK government initiative is aimed at resettling Afghan citizens who worked for or with the UK in Afghanistan and are at risk to life by the Taliban. Individuals are identified by the MOD and matched with local councils using the properties purchased through the Local Authority Housing Fund (LAHF).

The councillors who have proposed the motion want council leader Leigh Frost to write to the Home Office requesting that no further discretionary placements are made in Cornwall until local housing need is fully met. The motion also asks that the Home Office “recognises Cornwall’s existing housing pressures when making future decisions about refugee resettlement, asylum dispersal or related accommodation arrangements”.

Cllrs Tarrant and Craze, and their backers, have also requested a report setting out the current impact of discretionary resettlement schemes on housing supply, temporary accommodation and local services, including GP provision, hospitals schools and community support services.

Their motion wants the council to note that there are currently more than 800 households in temporary or emergency accommodation in Cornwall, including families with children and single people, and that there are over 20,000 households on the housing register, and “that this level of housing need is unacceptable and unsustainable”.

The proposers’ motion calls for the council to acknowledge “the humanitarian purpose of refugee resettlement schemes but believes that participation in discretionary schemes must be balanced against the council’s overriding duty to meet the urgent housing needs of residents already in Cornwall, including those who are homeless, in emergency or temporary accommodation, on the social housing register or leaving the Armed Forces”.

In a report to the council, its strategic lead for inclusion and belonging at Cornwall Council, formerly known as the resettlement team, wrote: “By accepting families, the council has a contract with the MOD for three years of integration support.

“By accepting LAHF accommodation, the council has a contract with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government [MHCLG] for three years use of the properties for Homes for Ukraine and Afghan Resettlement. The council cannot unilaterally cease meeting contractual obligations already entered into.

“Any decision to withdraw from future participation would require detailed review of contractual, grant funding and public law implications.”

Based on the current occupation and the dates of the last family arrivals, the council is under contract with various government departments until October 2029.

The officer’s report added: “There would be significant reputational and financial risk to the council in changing its approach and not meeting its existing and future commitments.”

It also states that related government funding has not only reduced pressure on local services but has also generated significant benefits over the last four years, including:

• £370,000 for school transport

• £489,795 for commissioned activity within the voluntary and community sector, benefiting residents with a range of vulnerabilities

• £242,079 spent with local businesses to meet programme requirements

• £50,338 invested in local communities to support integration and community cohesion.

Schools have also so far received a further £1,879,789 in separate funding to support the successful integration of resettled children and young people. The Integrated Care Board (ICB) has received £280,800 for GP and emergency care services, with a further £228,000 currently awaiting payment.

The officer’s report adds that fair access to housing has not been impacted by resettlement as housing legislation is scrupulously applied to all temporary accommodation and Home Choice housing register applications.

The motion will be debated by the full council at its meeting on Tuesday, November 24, at 10.30am at Lys Kernow (County Hall) in Truro.