A bid to increase the number of houses on a controversial housing development in St Mabyn has been seen off after the applicant was required to withdraw the application.
The Chapelfields development in St Mabyn has been subject to criticism from villagers and the town council for the time taken to build the development, in addition to persistent issues relating to the connection of the site to the wider sewerage network.
In 2025, the original developer behind the scheme became insolvent, with the site promptly branded a £9-million ‘dangerous eyesore’ by the area’s parish council.
In an application to Cornwall Council, the subsequent developer of the scheme sought the council’s approval to change the property types on certain developments from being a detached four-bedroom dwelling to being two semi-detached three bedroom dwellings.
While the application (PA26/05735) referred to Plot 16 on the site, the applicant stated that it would seek to do the same to plots 18, 19 and 25, potentially expanding the development from the approved 27 houses to 31 houses.
In the application, the developer stated that it had ‘viability challenges’ on the site, saying: “The developer has encountered significant viability challenges in delivering the remainder of the scheme. In particular, the larger open-market dwellings included within the approved scheme have proven difficult to sell in current market conditions.
“This has directly impacted cash flow and the developer’s ability to further fund the Affordable Housing of the development as it currently stands. As a result, the S106 conditions in relation to the Affordable Housing conditions in its current approved form is no longer viable.
“Furthermore, in a recent public meeting led by the St Mabyn Parish Council, it was noted that St Mabyn is in need of more family housing in the more affordable price bracket as opposed to the more expensive market. It is considered that by providing smaller, three-bedroom units on site, will allow this development to cater for this requirement and the homes will be more attractive to aspiring residents of St Mabyn.
“To enable the development to proceed and be completed, the developer proposes a revised scheme for four of the open market plots which are: Plots 16, 18, 19 and 25. The overall intention is to amend the designs within the same footprint as previously approved. Specifically, the developer proposes to substitute the previously approved four-bedroom detached dwellings with four pairs of three-bedroom semi-detached homes.”
Prior to its withdrawal, residents in the local area, including some who live on completed properties at the site, objected to the proposal.
The objectors included Mr Neil Bishop, who said: “The whole viability argument rests on the idea that the four-bedroom detached houses are difficult to sell. That isn't borne out by the sales history on this site. The majority of the detached plots built or planned so far, were sold off-plan and sold quickly. The problem hasn't been finding buyers; it's been keeping them.
“To my knowledge, at least five couples who had agreed to buy larger plots later pulled out. The reasons they pulled out are the important bit, because they have nothing to do with the housing market.”
Another of the seven objectors, Miss Charlotte Burnard said in her objection: “When we bought our property, we did so based on the original approved plans and the size, layout and overall feel of the development.
“We chose to live here knowing how the estate was meant to look and I am concerned that increasing the number of houses will change its character and put additional pressure on parking, traffic and the space between properties.
“I am particularly concerned that the developer is proposing to build additional houses when there are still outstanding works on the existing estate.
“We have experienced ongoing issues with the completion of the development, and it is frustrating to see further changes being proposed when the original works have still not been completed. What guarantees are there that allowing more houses will actually result in the estate being finished properly?”
A meeting of St Mabyn Parish Council noted the reason for the application being withdrawn, with the minutes stating: “Apparently, it is not a viable option for them to finish the site as per the original planning application and the Developer wants to change Plot 16 from a four bedroom detached house to two three bedroom semi detached dwellings.
“However, it is not allowed to increase the number of dwellings on the site, cannot go beyond the originally agreed 27 dwellings, and they have been advised to withdraw the application PA26/05735.
“Cllr Moorcroft (the Cornwall Council member for the area) has asked for a condition to be put on that will mean no changes to the plans until the pump is repaired and running to enable SWW to connect the sewage etc.
“SWW has confirmed that there have not been any conversations with either Allevo or Landmark Estates. There are properties to be demolished but it is unclear how many.”
Find out about planning applications that affect you by visiting the Public Notice Portal.
At that meeting, councillors resolved to object to the application although it has since been withdrawn, meaning that if the applicant wishes to pursue the changes in properties to increase the size of the development beyond 27 dwellings, it must seek a new planning permission to do so as opposed to an amendment to the existing permission.




.jpeg?width=209&height=140&crop=209:145,smart&quality=75)

Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.