THE trial of former Methodist minister Steven Wild has reached its final stages at Truro Crown Court, with the jury hearing the closing comments of the prosecution and defence barristers, and legal directions from the judge.
Wild, who is 72 and from St Ives, is the former chair of Cornwall district for the Methodist church and a one-time holder of its highest office, that of conference president. He was suspended from ministry in September 2021.
He stands accused of 10 counts of sexual assault and one count of indecent assault between 2004 and 2019. The alleged incidents are said to have taken place in Cornwall, the Isles of Scilly, Devon, Southport, Bristol and Derbyshire. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
In his closing speech, prosecution barrister Brian Fitzherbert said the initial questions had been “did it happen?” and “was it sexual?”
“A hand up a skirt is obviously sexual touching. Cupping a bottom is obviously sexual touching,” he said. “If you are sure the touching happened, then the prosecution case is that your verdict should be guilty.”
He referred to the similarities between some of the accounts, namely the stroking of the small of the back, and the placing of a hand on the upper thigh under a table while telling a story, alleged separately by two women who had both been interviewed for positions in the Methodist church with Wild sitting on the panel.
“All the allegations are similar; they involve disguised sexual touching in the context of his role as a Methodist minister – subtle sexual touch that could be explained away.
“The fact the events were in public, given his status and reputation, was a protection as he could say, ‘hang on – there were loads of people around’; and he could rely on others to say ‘that’s just Steve being Steve’, and no one looked too closely at how he touched people because he was always touching people.”
Mr Fitzherbert added that to put a woman upset about being touched in a room with the alleged perpetrator and “another male Methodist minister who had known him for 20 years was as effective at dealing with the situation as you would imagine – it’s no surprise that seven reviews were required between 2019 and 2021 to put safeguarding in Cornwall in order.”
“None of these women are lying. They all know they are not alone, but they did not know the details. They all say similar things for a simple reason – they experienced it at the hands of the same man. It did happen, and if it did happen, each instance was a sexual or indecent assault.”
He concluded: “At moments of high excitement, Mr Wild liked to touch women in sexual ways. If you are sure of that, then he’s guilty of the offences on the indictment.”
Taking the stand, defence barrister Heather Hope said: “All of this was happening ‘in plain sight’, but no one saw it happen. As you were listening to the evidence, you may have thought, ‘Where are the people who were there, the people who could assist us with what they saw?’ The prosecution evidence relies on the accuracy of each of these allegations, made by each of the complainants.”
Specifically regarding the first complainant, whose alleged incidents date back as far as 2004, Ms Hope pointed to the lack of eyewitnesses to back up the woman’s account, the only witness called being her counsellor, also a Methodist minister, who she had confided in on the first occasion. “The trouble is, you are dealing with what she says and what Mr Wild says,” she said.
The second complainant alleged Wild had cupped her bottom during a hug at a large event; having told her then-partner, she admitted they had joked about it over the years. Ms Hope said: “In the telling of a story, sometimes things change, sometimes things are embellished, sometimes things are misremembered … They say, ‘never let the truth get in the way of a good story’.”
She added: “Why would he do that in those circumstances, with so many people around, to just one woman?” She also reminded the jury that the second and fourth complainants had been in touch with each other prior to the trial, and “we cannot know what has or hasn’t been said”.
Regarding the oft-mentioned response of Wild’s ‘tactile’ nature as “just Steve being Steve”, Ms Hope said: “There’s a difference between being tactile and touching people in a sexualised way, and you may think that those people who were present would know the difference.”
Referring to high-profile cases currently in the national media, she entreated the jury: “You will be very conscious of everything that’s being said at the moment about the way men behave towards women. Whatever you think, that is not part of this case, and you must try this case on the evidence.”
Ms Hope reminded the jury that male witnesses had confirmed Wild had touched them too, on the leg and with a kiss on the forehead. She conceded her client “could from time to time divide opinion”, adding: “The prosecution does not call everyone who dislikes Steven Wild, and we do not call everyone who likes him … You may think fundamentally he is a good person, that he has a strong faith and has spent his life trying to share that faith with others.”
She concluded: “All we can do is say, this is a man who has put himself in your hands to do that weighing and judging, and we ask you to do that carefully. When you evaluate the question, the right and proper verdict in this case is one of not guilty.”
In his legal directions, Recorder Richard Stead explained to the jury that they must reach a verdict based on “your experience of life but in a dispassionate way, and only on the evidence you have heard in this court”.
He added: “It would be understandable if you came to this trial with an idea of what constitutes sexual offence – what kind of person might be a victim or an offender. You must leave behind any such assumptions. Experience tells us there is no stereotype when it comes to sexual offending; it may involve any circumstances and all kinds of different people.”
He said victims “may react in a variety of different ways to what has happened”, adding: “There is no normal reaction to a sexual offence.” Several factors including “shame, shock, confusion, fear of getting into trouble, not being believed or causing problems for other people” might be reasons why women would not report sexual assault immediately.
He went through each count, one of indecent assault and 10 of sexual assault, explaining that the jury would need to ask four questions: if it was sure intentional touching took place; if so, whether a reasonable person would consider that touching to be indecent or sexual in nature; whether the complainant had given her consent, and whether Wild genuinely believed consent had been given and had sufficient reason to do so.
“If you answer to any of these questions is ‘not sure’, then your verdict should be ‘not guilty’.”
The day ended with the judge’s summing up of the evidence, to be continued tomorrow, following which the jury will retire to consider its verdict.

.jpg?trim=0,0,3,0&width=752&height=422&crop=752:422)




Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.